top of page

Same Output. Different Economics.

Writer: Davie Thomson
Davie Thomson
10 minutes ago
7 min read

Why businesses delivering the same output can have very different margins, cash requirements and capacity for growth.

I've spent much of my working life in manufacturing businesses, and one thing that has always interested me is how two apparently similar operations can deliver much the same output while consuming very different amounts of money and resources.

Both may be profitable. Both may satisfy their customers and meet their production targets. Yet one might hold twice as much inventory, employ considerably more people or operate equipment that ought to have been replaced or reconfigured years earlier.

Management will generally have an explanation for these differences. The product mix is difficult, the equipment is old, customers are demanding, suppliers are unreliable, or the factory was never designed to operate at today's volumes.

Some of those explanations will be entirely legitimate. Others will have become convenient justifications for operating conditions that nobody seriously questions anymore.

The difficulty is establishing which is which.

 

Two pumps, two pipes


Consider a simple illustration involving two systems designed to deliver water from one point to another.

Both deliver 1,000 litres per minute.

The first has a relatively straightforward arrangement of pipework, a correctly specified pump and the necessary controls to deliver the required flow reliably.

The second has evolved over time. Additional pipework has been installed, modifications have introduced restrictions, and operating problems have been accommodated through equipment changes and adjustments to the way the system is managed.

To maintain the same output, the second system now requires a larger pump operating at a higher pressure.



In our illustrative comparison, the first system requires an input of 1,100 litres per minute, while the second requires 1,500 litres to deliver the same 1,000 litres of useful output.

The first holds approximately 1,150 litres of water within the system. The second holds 1,700 litres. Their respective transit times are 60 and 80 seconds.

These are illustrative specifications rather than a hydraulic design calculation, but they expose some important differences.

The second system costs more to operate, holds more water and takes longer to deliver the same output.

Now imagine that both systems belong to different companies, each reporting production of 1,000 litres per minute.

Looking at output alone, how would we distinguish between them?

And what happens if demand increases to 1,200 litres per minute?

The first system may have sufficient capacity to accommodate the increase. The second might already be operating at its limit, with the pump, pipework or some other component preventing any further increase in output.

We would need to establish the actual constraints and available capacity before drawing that conclusion. Nevertheless, the possibility raises an important question.

How many businesses believe they're operating at capacity when, in fact, their operating conditions are consuming capacity they ought to have available?


What should the enterprise be capable of?


This is where I introduce the distinction between what I call The Essence and The Timeline.

The Essence describes the operating conditions an enterprise should reasonably be capable of achieving, consistent with its obligations to customers, suppliers and other stakeholders.

It isn't an imaginary perfect factory. Every business needs appropriate inventory, capacity protection, maintenance and provision for variability. The task is to establish what is genuinely necessary to operate reliably under the conditions the enterprise faces.

The Timeline describes what actually happens.

It captures the real journey of Material, Money and Information through the enterprise, from suppliers and purchasing through raw materials, work in progress, finished goods, customers and receivables.

Information is particularly important because it governs much of what happens along that journey. What gets ordered, when work is released, what gets produced, how priorities are established and how exceptions are handled all depend upon the quality and timeliness of information and decisions.

An unnecessary approval, inaccurate inventory record or delayed decision can be every bit as disruptive as a physical obstruction to material movement.

The difference between the operating conditions represented by The Essence and those experienced in The Timeline is what I call Drift.

And Drift can originate in two quite different ways.


The system we designed, and the system we manage


Designed-in System Drift is the inefficiency embedded in the way the enterprise has been configured.

It might arise from the original factory design, subsequent expansion, inherited equipment, organisational arrangements or processes developed to accommodate yesterday's requirements.

I've encountered factories where material travels considerable distances between operations, equipment configurations dictate unnecessarily large batches, and production arrangements have long since ceased to reflect what customers actually require.

These aren't necessarily the consequence of poor day-to-day management. Frequently, the people running the operation are doing a perfectly reasonable job with the system they've inherited.

Management Drift arises from the way that system is operated and controlled.

Breakdowns, defects, rework, interruptions, poor changeover performance, inappropriate scheduling decisions, inaccurate information and inadequate control of work in progress all contribute.

The two forms of Drift can reinforce one another. A poorly configured system demands additional management effort to keep it operating, while weak management practices can aggravate the problems inherent in its design.

What concerns me is how readily businesses become accustomed to compensating for both.

An additional shift is introduced, safety stocks increase, another forklift is acquired, more supervisors are appointed or additional capacity is purchased. Individually, these decisions may appear entirely sensible.

Taken together, they can conceal the extent to which the enterprise has departed from the conditions it ought to be capable of achieving.

Drift, Time Lag and the money

Both types of Drift can increase operating costs and extend the time required to complete work.

I distinguish the additional elapsed time as Time Lag — the difference between the journey represented by The Essence and the actual journey experienced in The Timeline.

The distinction matters because the financial consequences are different.

Drift predominantly affects Margin, through the additional cost of operating under less favourable conditions.

Time Lag predominantly affects Cash, through the additional time that money remains committed to inventory, production and the wider cash conversion cycle.

Both can also affect Revenue, particularly where the operating conditions restrict the enterprise's ability to fulfil additional demand.

These relationships aren't exclusive. Additional elapsed time can itself create operating costs, while poor operating conditions can constrain capacity without necessarily extending the lead time of every product.


Return to our two pipe systems.


The additional pumping effort and losses have a margin consequence. The extra water held in the system represents additional capital committed to sustaining the same output. The longer transit time illustrates Time Lag, while the possibility of a capacity ceiling introduces the revenue question.

Manufacturing enterprises exhibit the same relationships, although the causes and financial consequences are generally more complicated.

A poor layout may require additional handling resources while extending manufacturing lead time. Excessive changeover times may encourage larger batches, increasing inventory and the time products spend waiting. Quality failures consume resources in producing replacements and may disrupt the production schedule.

Information delays can produce similar consequences. A production order released against inaccurate stock records, for example, may generate shortages, rescheduling, interruptions and additional work in progress without increasing output.

The relationship between time and economic value is particularly important here.

An hour recovered at a resource constraining saleable output may be extremely valuable. An hour recovered elsewhere may improve flexibility, reduce costs or help shorten lead times, but contribute nothing to additional revenue.

The financial benefit depends upon where the time is recovered, what it constrains and whether that benefit can actually be realised.

Simply recording hours saved tells us very little about the commercial value of the improvement.


Comfortably numb

I've seen plenty of businesses meeting their delivery targets while carrying far more inventory, spending more money and employing more resources than they ought to need.

Over time, these things become accepted. They're built into budgets, planning assumptions and everyday working practices. Nobody questions them because, as far as management is concerned, the business is performing.

They're what I describe in my book The Essence as comfortably numb.

The problem is particularly difficult to recognise when the enterprise has been operating under the same conditions for years. There may be nobody left who remembers why a particular arrangement was introduced, or whether the circumstances that justified it still exist.

I've also seen improvement programmes deliver impressive local results without materially changing the economics of the enterprise. Machines become more efficient, individual processes improve and productivity measures move in the right direction, yet inventory remains stubbornly high, lead times barely change and the financial results fail to reflect the effort expended.

That doesn't mean the improvements were worthless. It does suggest that the relationship between the improvement activity and the performance of the wider enterprise wasn't sufficiently understood.

A different starting point

Before deciding where to invest, what equipment to improve or which costs to remove, I believe leadership needs a clearer understanding of the conditions under which the business is actually operating.

  • What should the enterprise reasonably be capable of achieving with its available resources?

  • How does that compare with what it actually delivers?

  • How much of the difference has been designed into the system, and how much arises from the way it is managed?

  • Where is additional elapsed time tying up cash, where is Drift eroding margin, and where might the same conditions be restricting revenue?

Answering those questions requires more than a review of operating KPIs. It means examining how Material, Money and Information move through the enterprise, understanding the decisions and constraints that govern that journey, and establishing which parts of the current operating arrangement are genuinely necessary.

Only then can we make properly informed decisions about improvement, reconfiguration or further investment.

Our two water systems both delivered 1,000 litres per minute. On that measure, both were successful.

But the economics of delivering that output were substantially different.

I wonder how many businesses are operating in much the same way, satisfied that they're meeting their targets without understanding what those targets are costing them, or what they might be capable of achieving under different operating conditions.

Davie Thomson

Owner/Principal, Davie Thomson Ltd.

Author of The Timeline and The Essence

 

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page